Vai al contenuto
  • Silvio Renesto
    Silvio Renesto

    Sigma 100-400mm f/5-6.3 Contemporary and close-up photography

    Years ago, when fixed focal lenses ruled  undisputed, and  tele- zooms of the  100-400 range were rare and regarded with suspicion, because  at the longest end image quality was rather so-so,  Sigma had in its list two very good tele lenses: a 300mm f4 and a  400mm f5.6 labelled as  APO MACRO because they had low dispersion lenses and minimum  focusing distance  (1.2m  for the  300mm, 1.6m  for the 400mm)  that was really short in comparison to similar teleobjectives of other brands.

    The definition MACRO, if not precise (the maximum reproduction ratio was 1:3,3 for both lenses, thus not in the field of real macrophotography),  indicated however that  these lenses allowed to make very good close-ups  to big insects,, frogs and salamanders, reptiles, flower and other  fairly small subject,  that  stood out of the background  and keeping a good  working distance  (safe for us or for the subject it depends ;) ) . When  mounted on a APS-C Dsrl,  a nearly true macro reproduction ratio (approx. 1:2) could be reached, thanks to the crop factor of the smaller sensor.  And  the image quality was very good.

    Unfortunately these lenses were off list before the digital era and only used samples were available, but they had compatibility issues with digital cameras,  mainly concerning focus accuracy.  Only in  few  samples focus errors  could be corrected by in-camera fine tuning, some others were unusable due to extreme back/front focus. It was a pity because with a good sample excellent images could be obtained.

     

    pedemontanum8hr.thumb.jpg.b9c673e6383af7b8b5e64d82c8b063e9.jpg

    This picture of a male Banded Darter (Sympetrum pedemontanum) was taken with the old Sigma 300mm f4 APO MACRO

    These tele lenses were replaced by 70-300 Macro zooms of different brands, that allowed to reach even 1:2 reproduction ratio, but image quality did not keep uo with new high density sensors. 

    And now Sigma suprised all with the new 100-400mm f 4-6.3 Contemporary  that shows very good to excellent performances especially at the long end as demonstrated by  Mauro Maratta in his reviews here on Nikonland.  In addition to  the good things already described by Mauro, the 100-400 Sigma has a minimum focusing distance nearly identical to the old  Sigma 400mm f 5.6 APO MACRO, that is about 1.6m. This made me curious to try it in close-up photography. 

    myself2.thumb.jpg.c3244c33cb09a1878b0d3192898bcf61.jpg

    The Sigma 100-400 can be easily used hand held even in close-up photography

     

    The  differences between the old 400mm and the new 100-400  zoom (other than the obvious fact that one is a fixed lens and the other is a zoom) can be quickly and easily explained for what concerns close up photography: Image  quality is visibly better in the zoom , with respect to the old 400mm, while the the reproduction ratio  (at 400mm) is somewhat lower (1:4 for the zoom vs  1:3,3 for the old 400mm).This is due to a greater reduction of the actual focal length at closer distances (focus breathing)  where the zoom at 400mm at the minimum focusing distance is actually a  256mm,  while the old 400mm  became a 330mm , the difference is not great, but visible.

    Thus the performances in close-up photography are somewhat lower, especially on full format sensor cameras. For relatively big subjects there are no  real problems and the versatility of the lens remains amazing:

    ninfea.thumb.jpg.8d6e65d8a868b8a213faa36ccd2eae5e.jpg

    fioriD610.thumb.jpg.0b39e528b965d7a6c913f30477e5d62e.jpg

     

    legno.thumb.jpg.fdc6fea4348560af32f0be3a8f6ce0d3.jpg

     

     

     While for little subjects like the Licenid butterfly below, it shows some limits.

    licenideD610.thumb.jpg.e0264e8b23fcb231af3dd690add7d0b8.jpg

     

    Things improve a lot when the zoom is coupled with an APS-C Dsrl camera.  The crop factor allow to take more than  satisfying close-ups.

    comparformat.thumb.jpg.aacab4067fcf4f904ca2f980ed30b47d.jpg

    cup1.jpg.9ddf82c647fc81770441a06bda55467e.jpg

    100% Crop of the image taken with D7100. Great image quality.

    orthetrum610.thumb.jpg.f59105c8eedfd6998984a3cefa85da8a.jpg

     

    orthetrum7100.thumb.jpg.c3c9633344a1fe37110a7552faf967b0.jpg

    Southern Skimmer (Orthetrum brunneum); above,  taken with Nikon D610, below  with  Nikon D7100, same distance.

    cup3.jpg.add0118c4352fe369f04cf54bdce0e00.jpg

    Crop 100% of the image above. You can see elements of the compound  eye  (ommatidia).

    volucella610.thumb.jpg.ba2cd5caa324f3a48517f3c8a01f4e50.jpg

     

    volucella7100.thumb.jpg.aa75f25772e05a666de402b4f702f777.jpg

                                                                                                                     Volucella, a large fly. Above D610, below D7100, same distance.

    The same applies for wildlife. On an APS-C Dsrl  the zoom becomes a 200-600 equivalent , light and portable. Coupled with an high performance Dx camera like the Nikon D500 , the zoom may make a perfect combination of good quality and portability  especially for BIF (Bird in Flight) photography.

     

    ibis.thumb.jpg.774f318e9e731501800a510d32452b54.jpg

    These Ibises aren't really in flight, but they give an idea.

    Performance with close up achromat lenses.

    A way to bypass the smaller reproduction ratio is to mount a close up achromat filter/lens, with the zoom set at mid-range (200-300mm) where the combo works at its best.  In the following images I coupled the zoom with a  Canon 500D achromatic close up lens ( 2 diopters) that combines excellent quality with moderate strength. Results made me enthusiast,  also on full format cameras, free handed and with af.

     

    exuvialente.thumb.jpg.2b9ebd8d81bdde2a7b4cd83fafda3e22.jpg

    A dragonfly Exuvia (remains of the larva after the adult emerged). Nikon D610, Sigma 100-400 (at 210mm), Canon 500D close up lens , and an ant on the left.

    liblente.thumb.jpg.bc943ae461dfe66600e0fd16364cf34a.jpg

    Blue Chaser (Libellula fulva) Sigma 100-400 (at 210mm), Nikon D610, Canon 500D close up lens. Hand held.

     

    liblentecup.jpg.f443accfaf4a5bc9fce4b48059cf82af.jpg

    Crop 100% of the image above , again you can see the elements of the compound eye .

    In these photos focus was set to infinity (actual distance from the front element was 50cm) ,  by focusing at closer distances it becomes possible to get into the range of true macro, especially at 250-300mm. It is advisable however to stay at infinity because the more you get close  the harder it becomes to manage depth of field, vibrations and the like. The same problems occur if you zoom beyond 300mm.  Anyway, let me repeat it: the combo made by this zoom plus a moderate  achromat close-up lens  is stunning. Even of a full format body.

     

    In conclusion. For close up photography, the zoom on a full format (Nikon:Fx) camera body allows to obtain satisfactory results with flowers and small mammals,  while it shows some limitations for smaller subjects.  On a APS-C (nikon:Dx) instead it is very good also for dragonflies , butterflies and other not too small critters. Alternatively it can be coupled with an unobtrusive good quality  close up lens (same size of a filter)  to obtain an extremely versatile kit for close-up, but I would say for nature photography in general, no matter what is the size of the  camera sensor.

    Thanks to Mauro Maratta for the loan of the lens for the test (even if it make me want one!) :) 

    mamyialogo.jpg.671e4a71c248d63216f048da215591e9.jpg

    Thanks to Mtrading, the Italian dealer of Sigma products,  for kindly making the lens available for testing by Nikonland staff.

    Modificato da Silvio Renesto

    Feedback utente

    Commenti Raccomandati

    Non ci sono commenti da visualizzare.



    Partecipa alla conversazione

    Puoi pubblicare ora e registrarti più tardi. Se hai un account, accedi ora per pubblicarlo con il tuo account.

    Ospite
    Aggiungi un commento...

    ×   Hai incollato il contenuto con la formattazione.   Rimuovere la formattazione

      Sono consentiti solo 75 emoticon max.

    ×   Il tuo collegamento è stato incorporato automaticamente.   Mostra come un collegamento

    ×   Il tuo contenuto precedente è stato ripristinato.   Pulisci editor

    ×   Non puoi incollare le immagini direttamente. Carica o inserisci immagini dall'URL.


×
×
  • Crea Nuovo...